Techtite's DVD Reviews!

--------------
MAIN PAGE
--------------
Reviews :
PC Games
Macintosh 
DVDs (& VHS!)
Movies (now playing)
Television
Gadgets & Gear
Hardcopy (Books)
Shows & Parks
X-box (360)
Playstation 3
Nintendo Wii
Game Cube
Nintendo DS
The PSP Page
Video Games (classic)
 

 Departments :

Snapshot of the Week:

  

Questions? Comments? Send Them To

Techtite Letters.

 

The Techtite Ratings System :

  • Burnout
  • Near Miss
  • Small Crater
  • Large Crater
  • Deep Impact

In Association with Amazon.com

America's Sweethearts

 (Click movie title to order this DVD)

A Techtite Review

The Film: Somewhere, I think Macaulay Culkin is watching this film and saying, "No fair!" After all, everyone would be quite upset if the formerly "naughty little kid" --now a grown man-- decided to reprise his naughty little kid role, when he no longer fits the part. Suffice to say, he grew up. Meanwhile, Julia Roberts continuously wants us to see her in the Cinderella role...even if Richard Gere slipped a "Pretty Woman" glass slipper on her foot, nearly a dozen years ago. Regardless of having been a Hollywood Princess for years by now,  America's Sweethearts  wants us to view America's #1 Sweetheart as an under-appreciated girl, waiting for her knight in shining armor. What...again?

The major sales power of this direct-to-video script is its casting of the lead roles : Julia, John Cusack, Billy Crystal, and Catherine Zeta-Jones. Even supporting roles are played by impressive comedic talents like Hank Azaria and Alan Arkin. One can only wonder why such major stars agreed to a TV Movie plot such as this. Sure, it's a typical romantic fairy tale, and yet there really isn't anything here that's worthy of such talent.

The story is about a typical Hollywood couple --"America's Sweethearts"-- who in this case are Gwen Harrison (Zeta-Jones) and Eddie Thomas (Cusack). They are the typical Hollywood couple who star in movies together, yet hide an unhappy marriage underneath all the publicity-machine hype. Gwen is involved with a Spaniard (Azaria), while Eddie has sought the help of  a New-Age type therapist, hilariously played by Alan Arkin. Attempting to corral these stars for their next movie's promotional campaign, is the head of the studio publicity department, Lee Phillips (Billy Crystal, who helped write the film). Suffice to say, he has his work cut out for him...particularly when the film itself isn't even ready to show to the press!

In comes Julia Roberts as Kiki; Gwen's sister. She is also Gwen's assistant, which must have seemed believable in the black and white text of a script, though doesn't look right on screen. Julia Roberts as Catherine Zeta-Jones'...assistant? True, this wouldn't be the first Roberts film which needed a fair dose of fantasy; her entire career took root, as an abrasive hooker who could act sophisticated after one week with Richard Gere. However, Roberts acting like the wallflower just doesn't wash anymore. Some scenes --where she must deal with Gwen's spoiled-actress shenanigans-- even seem slightly hypocritical. Isn't Kiki played by the same actress who laughed like a hyena on stage, after winning her Best Actress Oscar in 2001...? Under-appreciated, indeed. In short, again, Julia is not right for the "Ugly Duckling" role anymore.

I'm hesitant to mention any more of the story. However, is the remainder of the story any surprise? Kiki realizes she has feelings for Eddie, and vice-versa. Meanwhile, Gwen is his wife, though not really, though enough to keep you entertained at the alleged love triangle. That's about the whole script, and it's a "spoiler" only to someone who's never seen a single romance film in 50 years. One more thing, Mr. Crystal; you really need to edit out at least 12 men's-crotch-jokes here; the remaining 50 crotch jokes are enough. Okay, enough "spoilers"...this film's dated script is spoiled enough.

I think what irks me the most about this picture is the obvious: Zeta-Jones and Roberts should have traded roles. It is Zeta-Jones who is the under-appreciated struggling  Hollywood newcomer, trying to escape the shadow of the Oscar-Winning Roberts. One might even suspect that the casting agents considered this, yet Roberts demanded the lead role. That thought alone is reason enough to not believe any scene she's in, as the under-appreciated sister hiding in her prettier sister's shadow.

I have little good to say for this picture, aside from casting...though admittedly, what a casting coup it is! The likeable talent of this picture demands that I rate it higher than merely a "burnout." However, let's just say rating this picture a "marginal thumbs down" is putting it a bit mildly.

The DVD: Not much to report on the DVD version of this film, aside from the film trailer and deleted scenes. However, in this case the deleted scenes are no big whoop, and seem inserted merely because someone in marketing said, "Dude, DVDs that offer only the trailer just don't sell." Indeed they don't, though it doesn't seem like thid DVD will be anything other than rented, with or without the deletions.

Final Rating : Near Miss. Simply put, Zeta-Jones and Roberts should have traded roles. Aside from casting, this films' a real disappointment.

For more on this site's ratings system, click here.

 

 

Got a review you'd like to share? Techtite will post 2 of the best "guest" reviews received for each item, online, for all the world to see!

 

All text, Title graphics, and pix not of reviewed product, are created by Techtite, copyright 2001; all rights reserved. For further "legalese" & disclaimers, click here...