Techtite's DVD Reviews!

 

 

"The conflict of how to rate this movie begins with two pairs of main stars: two that portray their characters exactly like they were in the cartoon, and two who wanted to improvise."

---from the review

------------------

Also Reviewed elsewhere:

cover

  The Best of Scooby Doo on DVD

cover

Scooby-Doo: Night of 100 Frights! for Playstation-2.

-------------

Sidebar ::

-------------

The overseas get a more intelligent ad campaign...? Above is the overseas version of the Scooby Doo poster. I don't know; I like it better than the one for U.S. release (the blue "SD" behind the gang). It seems a bit more foreboding, though in a PG sort of way (a la those Mummy movies). Don't you think?

--------------
MAIN PAGE
--------------
Reviews:
PC Games
Macintosh 
Television
DVD & BluRay
Gadgets & Gear
Hardcopy (Books)
Shows & Parks
X-box (360)
Playstation 3
Nintendo Wii
Game Cube
Portables
(PSP, DS, iPhone, iPad)
Video Games (classic)
 

 Departments :

Techtite's Latest YouTube Video!:

  

Questions? Comments? Send Them To

Techtite Letters.

 

The Techtite Ratings System :

  • Burnout
  • Near Miss
  • Small Crater
  • Large Crater
  • Deep Impact

In Association with Amazon.com

Scooby Doo (2002)

cover

Click picture to order this film (widescreen)

Film Also available in Full Screen: Click Here.

A Techtite Review

The Film: Scooby-Doo was a mainstay of Saturday mornings in my youth. I am not one of those Generation-X critics who would purport otherwise, nor am I about to poo-poo my single-digit years, implying I was reading the newspaper and sipping tea back in the day, rather than watching cartoons and being, quite predictably, a child. Nor would I imply that Scooby-Doo was worthy of being among the Top Ten Cartoon Ideas Gone Awry; see that list if you dare, and be enlightened. I may, admittedly, prefer a Superfriends movie someday, though the point is, I know what I'm reviewing here.

One must admit this much: making this cartoon live-action was no easy task. Memories of last year's Josie and the Pussycats surface --as much as I wish they would not-- where it was obvious the directors had never seen a single cartoon from that series! This film's prologue is irrefutably by people who actually saw the cartoons. There's Daphne in trouble, buzz words like "Zoinks!" and "Jinkies!" and in the end, a ghoul is caught and unmasked. Pamela Anderson --apparently, a modern substitute for Phyllis Diller-- even makes a cameo appearance.

The main story begins when Fred (Freddie Prinze, Jr.) takes all the credit for the mystery being solved, annoying the others in the group. This leads to Fred, Velma (Linda Cardellini), and Daphne (Sarah Michelle Gellar), all deciding to split up, with only Shaggy (Matthew Lillard) and Scooby (CGI animated) alone with the Mystery Van, uttering the movie's core theme: "Friends Stick Together." Jump ahead 2 years, when an owner of "Spooky Island" (Rowan Atkinson), requires their combined efforts, to solve a particularly haunting mystery. Will this mystery bring them back together? Well, it wouldn't be much of a Scooby movie if it didn't.

The conflict of how to rate this movie begins with two pairs of main stars: two that portray their characters exactly like they were in the cartoon, and two who wanted to improvise. Freddie Prinze Jr.'s alteration of Fred Jones, from "hunky leader of the group" into "dizzy blond" was, I feel, a mistake. This may have been intended to accentuate his real-life fiancée Gellar's transformation of Daphne, from "Danger prone" victim to, suddenly, kung-fu heroine; again, a mistake, since this is not Daphne's style. However, the "cute factor" of these two stars make their snafus more palatable than they could have been. Meanwhile, Cardellini's Velma, and Lillard's Shaggy, are dead-on perfect, from Velma's blindly crawling on the ground for her glasses when monsters are nearby, to Shaggy's Casey-Kasem-like voice.

However, given Scooby's alternate incantations throughout the years, there are any number of Scooby fans with their own, precise view of what a live-action Scooby flick should look like. This film, quite obviously, will only appease an elite group of them. Are you among them? That depends. There are those, for example, who look at Scooby's nephew, Scrappy-Doo, as the irrefutable pinnacle of the show's downfall; the puppy know-it-all with no fears, who at one point, even replaced Fred and Velma in the series! If you're a Scrappy lover, well, I hope you have a good sense of humor. For Scrappy haters, his harsh treatment here is worth the price of the whole film. For me, I'll only admit the comment that Scrappy was no real puppy --it was a glandular disorder-- was worth a hearty laugh.

Unfortunately, two ideas for where to go with this film apparently surfaced: one modern, one classic. The film obviously originally filmed the former, then was edited to appease fans of the latter. The gritty mystery, for example, involves a machine that removes teenager's souls and replaces them with "demon souls."  Little tykes too young to know how unlikely such a machine is, may leave with mild nightmares. There are poor edit jobs implying there used to be PG-13 jokes to go along with this PG-13 mystery, yet only the potty humor remains: a flatulence contest between Shaggy and Scooby, and a moment when a very rebellious Scrappy "marks his territory" (ahem) on Daphne. On the other hand, such potty humor never crosses the line to sewer humor (Austin Powers 2 comes to mind), so I was still able to have a good time with the kids...who, admittedly, are who the film was made for.

In the end, what to rate this film? Well, this is truly a film for the kids, so let them decide (a little). I went to this film with no less than 4 youngsters under the age of 8, and they all loved it. In fact, my 5 year old nephew was disgruntled that he was unable to see it a second time right away! What did you expect? The sad fact of life is, with only the bare-minimum of exceptions, even a homage to 1970's animation is better than most children's entertainment these days. Zoinks! Not THAT'S scary!

The DVD: The audio commentaries are twofold: one with the cast, one with the crew. The latter is nice from a technical-anecdotes standpoint, yet it's the commentary from Matthew Lillard, Freddie Prinze Jr., Sarah Michelle Gellar, and Linda Cardellini that truly shines. From as soon as they finish with the introductions, it's clear that this will be a fun commentary, for one reason; this is a cast unafraid to laugh at themselves. This is far more fresh than commentaries like the one for The Sweetest Thing, where stars gushed about how "perfect" everything was. Face reality; things are hardly perfect, in even the finest of films. This cast is humble enough to admit this, leading to a great time.

Let's jump to the deleted scenes. While not offered individually, you can use chapter skip to jump to the deleted scenes that sound best to you. Scene one is a far better opening credit sequence (WHY did they delete this?!?), where animated versions of the characters introduce the film far more brilliantly than the film did, which incorrectly jumped right to the mystery. Scene two, by stark contrast, is a forgettable moment when the gang catches each other up on what they've done since they broke up as a team. Let's just say the stories are worth deleting.

More deletions. "Mystery Boulevard" shows more of the Island than we saw in the film, where each of the gang is given a more scenic tour. This includes the scene only viewed in the film trailer (!), when Velma describes herself as "the smart one" to someone who's never heard of the Scooby Gang. Speaking of Velma, actress Linda Cardellini is the star attraction of the next two --and best-- deleted scenes! The first, "Velma's Song," has a drunk Velma strutting her stuff on top of the lounge piano. The second, "Locker Room," has Velma's doppelganger in a bikini ---Jinkies! The deleted scenes end with "Daphne's Spirit Thingie" when her spirit first gets yanked out (probably deemed too intense for the younger kids), and "heart attack," when Scooby tries the oldest trick in he book to get free from the villains' cage.

While these are some nice deletions to enjoy --and en even better cast commentary-- what else is there? Well, there's a 21 minute, behind-the-scenes featurette that apparently was first shown on TV (hence the only 21 minute length, sans commercials). There's also a "two player game" to enjoy, yet with DVD-only interaction, you can imagine how little this "game" will sway kids from wanting to play a round of Scooby Doo: Night of 100 Frights instead. Capping off the extras (click on the "next" arrow at the bottom-right of the main menu) is the obligatory music video (Outkast's "The Land of a Billion Drums"), and three short clips on how they designed the set, built the Mystery Van, and choreographed Daphne's Buffy-like fight scene. The only surprise? Try as I might, I could not find any of the film's trailers. Strange.

There is also one cute little Easter egg. In the main menu, Scooby dashes to pick up his "SD" tag in the bottom-middle. Wait until he drops it again if you have to, then highlight it and click Enter. You'll see a 70 second tale of rainy seasons at the film site they chose. Ruh-oh!

In the end, this was a good film...yet not great. So, why has WB given it the go ahead, for two more sequels? The answer is simple: because this could be a film franchise as lucrative as Star Trek's was, and if Trek got a second chance after that yawner of a Star Trek The Motion Picture, so should Scooby. Here's hoping the sequel guest stars Don Knotts! Until then...

 

Final Rating : Small Crater. Younger Scooby fans should be entertained. Shaggy fans should be quite pleased. Scrappy haters should be thrilled!

For more on this site's ratings system, click here.

 coverClick picture to order this film (widescreen)

Film Also available in Full Screen: Click Here.

Got a review you'd like to share? Techtite will post 2 of the best "guest" reviews received for any product, online, for all the world to see!

 

 

All text, Title graphics, and pix not of reviewed products, are created by Techtite, copyright 1999-2001; all rights reserved. Picture of DVD cover is used only for the purpose of review (and to make shopping for product easier); it by no means represents any affiliation with Techtite and the distributors of this product. For further "legalese" & disclaimers, click here...