Techtite's DVD Reviews!

 

 

 

"With such scoring [of the episodes; see review], good and classic vs. bad and ugly scores a mere 13 to 12 in favor of the season. While this is hardly very good, one perk pulls it over the top; like it or not, this "Phantom Menace" season of the TNG series set the scene for superior stories to come."

---from the review

--------------------

 

-------------

Sidebar ::

-------------

Plan your departures well. Denise Crosby wanted to leave the show early; by season end, so did Gates McFadden. However, McFadden had more time to think her character's absense through; she was merely transferred to another assignment. This made her season 3 return easy as pie. The same cannot be said, however, for Crosby's character, who was killed off and deemed too "illogical" (to quote Spock's classic cliche) to bring back to life as anyone other than a Romulan daughter caused by a time-shift (in a later season).

Was Wesley that bad...? No comment. Let's just say that dozens of fans who wanted to be a teenager on the bridge of the Enterprise were miffed as to why this kid got that honor and not them. So miffed were these fans, that even in the days when web sites were a rare commodity, anti-Wesley sites were among them. Of course, no such sites exist any more...or do they?

 

-----------------

Feel free to contribute. As always, review submissions are accepted!

------------------

--------------
MAIN PAGE
--------------
Reviews :
PC Games
Macintosh 
DVDs (& VHS!)
Movies (now playing)
Television
Gadgets & Gear
Hardcopy (Books)
Shows & Parks
X-box (360)
Playstation 3
Nintendo Wii
Game Cube
Nintendo DS
The PSP Page
Video Games (classic)
 

 Departments :

Snapshot of the Week:

  

Questions? Comments? Send Them To

Techtite Letters.

 

The Techtite Ratings System :

  • Burnout
  • Near Miss
  • Small Crater
  • Large Crater
  • Deep Impact

In Association with Amazon.com

Star Trek, The Next Generation: 

The Complete First Season

cover

Click picture to order this 7-disc DVD collection.

A Techtite Review

The Series : When the word was given for another Star Trek series, initial Star Trek fandom response was bittersweet. Trek, without Kirk, Spock, or McCoy? When reading character profiles of their apparent "replacements," I was discouraged. A robot who wishes to be human? A child "genius"...? Worst of all: a KLINGON on the bridge...as a friend? Even if such original-series "sacrilege" doesn't affect the non-Trekkie, the overall question remained: Why watch a different Trek?

Why indeed...however, such a question would only be slightly answered in season one, in a series which did not truly take hold until season three. While any fan of Star Trek: The Next Generation --or "TNG," as it's often abbreviated-- will tell you they "knew all along" that this series was a hit...they lie. Yes, Wesley Crusher was annoying. Yes, many episodes ripped off plots from the original series, as well as Battlestar Galactica and even Buck Rogers in the 24th Century. No, initial opinion wasn't too favorable...so much so, by the end of the season two major stars had departed the series, however temporarily: Denise "Tasha" Crosby, and Gates "Dr. Crusher" McFadden.

Was the first season that bad, or did it have any redeeming episodes at all? Allow me to take the next four paragraphs to summarize the good, the bad, the ugly...and the classic. Before you get your pen and pencil out to take score, it's: Good 10, Bad 6, Ugly 6 as well, and classic episodes amounting to...well, three:

The good: Encounter at Farpoint (a cameo by "Dr. McCoy" made the whole episode, which is a good thing; this pilot episode was little more than "Q" taking Enterprise to a planet to see two giant space octopi share a hug); The Naked Now (regardless of unintentional humor, this was a good glimpse at acting/character potential); The Battle (Picard's past ingeniously takes a foothold, via the return of his first ship, the Stargazer); The Big Goodbye (while the first of MANY "holodeck gone awry" episodes, Patrick Stewart as "Dixon Hill," plus other cast members in a 1930's-style detective mystery, allowed a nice change of pace for most of the cast); Datalore (Data's evil "brother" Lore is introduced); 11001001 (while this story of binary aliens taking over Enterprise was merely tolerable, Riker's "romance" with Minuet on the holodeck was worth the whole episode); Heart of Glory (the first true glimpse of Klingon culture, plus --cool!-- see what Geordi sees through his visor); The Arsenal of Freedom (a planet that destroyed itself with the very weapons it sold to others still has its automated "salesman" active); We'll Always Have Paris (guest star Michelle Phillips combines with Patrick Stewart for a very nice, old fashioned love-lost story); and The Neutral Zone (the season finale, which deserved thumbs-up only for the return of the infamous Romulans).

The bad: Where No One Has Gone Before (a nice lost-in-space plot is marred by an alien who just wanted to see Wesley "Amadeus Mozart" Crusher face to face); Angel One (Trek writers rip-off a cliché 1980's Buck Rogers plot where a planet has chauvinist female leaders who treat men as subordinate slaves); Too Short a Season (some old fool takes a youth serum with devastating results: BAD ACTING!); When the Bough Breaks (desperate alien parents steal the children of Enterprise, including Wesley!); Home Soil (a rip-off of the classic Trek episode "Devil in the Dark"; 'nuf said); and Coming of Age (while a nice hint at the Conspiracy story to come, this "Picard's record under scrutiny" story mixed with Wesley's Starfleet entrance exam was ho-hum).

The ugly: Code of Honor (probably the reason why Denise Crosby left, this has Tasha Yar teach an amorous alien a bit about modern feminism...oh goody!); The Last Outpost (the first sight of Ferengis was horrifically mishandled: "You work with your females...and force them to wear clothing! Ug! Ug!"); Lonely Among Us (a rip-off of Patrick Stewart's movie Lifeforce, this has some lightning entity offer cheap FX for a cheap episode); Justice (Wesley schleps his way into discovering that even the most minor crime on an idyllic planet is a capital offense); Skin of Evil (Tasha Yar is killed by, of all things, a living oil slick); ...and worst of all, Symbiosis (my LEAST FAVORITE Trek of all time, of any series, where Picard discovers that a planet of drug lords have addicted another planet to the point of total submission, only to decide "The Prime Directive" means he can just go along on his merry way. Where's Kirk to smack this imbecile upside the head...?).

The Debatable: Although possibly better put in a "sidebar," it deserves mentioning, as the first season of the series, all of the bold changes to TOS (The Original Series) that were attempted as of this next generation in Star Trek history. Wesley Crusher, for one, was pretty annoying; a kid who was put on the bridge of the flagship of the fleet...why? He was supposedly to Starfleet was Amadeus Mozart was to music, but as much as I admired Will Wheaton in Stand By Me, he just didn't give the role his all. He simply seemed like a Trekkie who patted the right backs and got a lead role in the series...and jealous Trekkies pretty much hated him for it. Of course, let's not single out Wesley Crusher as the bane of everything peculiar in Next Generation lore. There's the design of the ship (the saucer can divide from the rest of the ship...why?!?), the costumes (must've been really hot working in those; not half as fun looking as the slacks and T-shirt style outfits Kirk and Spock used to wear!), and furthermore, the way nearly every episode of this first season looked slightly ripped off from the first series.

Any classic episodes? To me, yes. There's Hide and Q, where Q's lesson in the human spirit has him offering Riker special powers. I loved the acting in that one, as well as Patrick Stewart's homage to a classic verse in Hamlet. Call me a Deanna Troi fan, though I really liked Haven; the first glimpse at "Betazoid" culture, as well as her personal past. The first guest appearance by Majel Barrett-Roddenberry --Nurse chapel in the 1960's series, and wife to series creator Gene Roddenberry-- enhanced this episode's classic appeal. Then there's Conspiracy --which for all intent, should have been the season's grand finale, and nearly was-- where a nice body-snatcher plot has Enterprise coming to the rescue of all of Starfleet. This latter episode would've made a cool movie; a compliment few other season one eps deserve.

With such scoring, good and classic vs. bad and ugly scores a mere 13 to 12 in favor of the season. While this is hardly very good, one perk pulls it over the top; like it or not, this "Phantom Menace" season of the TNG series set the scene for superior stories to come. It is also the first chance to see these actors in their roles, before they were later written into mostly two-dimensional caricatures of themselves by season 6 or 7. Unintentional humor enhances the fun, like the very bad overacting of Marina "Troi" Sirtis, who did not quite grasp as of yet how to portray her "empathic" character who senses everyone's emotions. A good drinking game for college kids involves taking a sip every time she says something like, "I sense....danger!"...which was often!

Should you buy this season? Absolutely! If you can only buy one season, though, should this be it? Nope; I'd opt for season 3, with a bit of overtime to pay off the purchase of season 4 as well. For people with the right cash flow, however, this season set the stage for not only classic Trek episodes later on; it set the scene for next-generation science fiction in general, which until 1987 was taking a very major dip downward. Thanks to this series, that soon changed. This alone is worth saluting the first season of the series...flawed as it might have been.

The DVD :  This DVD set consists of 7 DVDs, in a box that truly seems designed within a distant future. While with the same cardboard/plastic design of other season collections like The X-Files' season one and season two, this folded unit slips into a bigger box, which acts as an outer clam shell of sorts. Any Trekkie should be quite pleased at how thoroughly this protects the DVDs within.

Unfortunately, the passing of the late Gene Roddenberry means no decent audio commentary is possible, though this is a common sacrifice in a DVD set of a complete season. After all, there's not much space left for extras, among all the episodes. Such bonuses are instead offered on disc 7, and while much of the behind-the-scenes footage has already been seen at conventions, it's nice to 1)have it preserved on DVD, and 2) have it enhanced by additional anecdotes of the cast and crew now, edited into their anecdotes "then."

Such documentaries are divided by topic. "In the Beginning" offers insight into the conceptual design of the series upon initial casting and storyboard stages. "Selected Crew Analysis" includes many anecdotes from the stars through the years, filmed both during the series' initial season one run (check out the actual Entertainment Tonight clip, of her comments upon her leaving the series in "Skin of Evil"), as well as modern footage (see how well they've aged in 15 years). "The Making of a Legend" are anecdotes during production of the season itself (mostly by the crew, not the cast). Non-conventioneers will love the sights rarely seen in these clips, of a Michael Dorn sans "worf" Klingon makeup, and Brent Spiner without his contacts and "android" skin paint.

Last though not least is "Memorable Missions," which may not be the cast's favorite memories as much as their strongest. See Jonathan Frakes muse about his Skin of Evil dip into the slime pit, where he was merely told, "It's metamucil and printer ink. You'll be fine; get in it!" Levar Burton's anecdote is of course "Heart of Glory," where we get to see what the blind Geordi La Forge sees via his artificial-eyes visor. Patrick Stewart offers a blooper anecdote, while Denise Crosby offers an anecdote about her final episode as Tasha Yar, where the rest of the cast came on set wearing black armbands...showing how close they were behind the scenes. See Armin Shimmerman --best known as "Quark" on Deep Space Nine-- offer his anecdote about being a totally different Ferengi in "The Last Outpost." Dan Curry, special effects supervisor, offers a real hoot for the episode "Arsenal of Freedom," where he confesses the flying killer robot of that episode was in fact his child's giant Easter egg combined with a Legs panty hose container and painted to look metallic. Eat your heart out, ILM!

For a limited time (probably, for the duration of the year, at least), this season one set comes along with a computer data CD (both PC and Macintosh compatible). This additional disc --modeled around the 1999 program, The Star Trek TNG Companion--  includes all season one shooting scripts, extensive additional photos, episode summaries, and small video trailers of each episode as they were promoted on TV at the time. Nice addition, though if you're reading this at a time when this disc isn't included anymore, I must admit; seeing the cast together for the first time is reason enough to buy this set, freebies or not.

 

Final Rating : Large Crater. While the cast was not yet in touch with their characters, this season paved the road for the COOL seasons yet to come!

For more on this site's ratings system, click here.

cover

Click picture to order this 7-disc DVD collection.

 

Got a review you'd like to share? Techtite will post 2 of the best "guest" reviews received for any product, online, for all the world to see!

 

 

All text, Title graphics, and pix not of reviewed products, are created by Techtite, copyright 1999-2001; all rights reserved. Picture of DVD cover is used only for the purpose of review (and to make shopping for product easier); it by no means represents any affiliation with Techtite and the distributors of this product. For further "legalese" & disclaimers, click here...