Techtite's TV Reviews!

 

 

"I was about to offer an episode by episode commentary, a la the many seasons of Star Trek: The Next Generation... Then I found myself cutting and pasting Deep Impact icons on the better 99% of the entire season."

---from the review

--------------------

 

-------------

Sidebar ::

-------------

No sidebar comments for this review. Yet...

 

-----------------

Feel free to contribute. As always, review submissions are accepted!

------------------

--------------
MAIN PAGE
--------------
Reviews:
PC Games
Macintosh 
Television
DVD & BluRay
Gadgets & Gear
Hardcopy (Books)
Shows & Parks
X-box (360)
Playstation 3
Nintendo Wii
Game Cube
Portables
(PSP, DS, iPhone, iPad)
Video Games (classic)
 

 Departments :

Techtite's Latest YouTube Video!:

  

Questions? Comments? Send Them To

Techtite Letters.

 

The Techtite Ratings System :

  • Burnout
  • Near Miss
  • Small Crater
  • Large Crater
  • Deep Impact

In Association with Amazon.com

Star Trek, The Original Series: 

The Complete First Season

Click pictures to order this season on DVD

A Techtite Review

The Series :  Forget The Next Generation. Forget Deep Space Nine. Forget Voyager, and any Enterprise other than that of Captain James T. Kirk. The truth is: Star Trek as it originally was in 1967 was a definitive pinnacle in sci-fi television. Prior to Kirk, McCoy, and Spock, all sci-fi was a cliché within a cliché; a world of a thousand flying saucers, a million rocket ships and not a single piece of imagination between them. Star Trek changed all that...or more specifically, series creator Gene Roddenberry did. The rest is not just sci-fi history; it was a television phenomenon.

So, why the long wait for it on DVD? Because originally, the series was only sold as two-episode DVD sets; that's why. Whatever. The point is that the full season sets are being released now, and they're even in totally cool packaging; the first season being in the same color as Captain Kirks' gold uniform, with later seasons in the same colors worn by Spock/McCoy (Blue) and Scotty/Uhura (Red). They also have a ton of extras --particularly this first season!-- as reviewed later on this page.

However, how good were these episodes...really? I was about to offer an episode by episode commentary, a la the many seasons of Star Trek: The Next Generation (whose best season to this Trek fan, in case you were asking, is season three). Then I found myself cutting and pasting Deep Impact icons on the better 99% of the entire season. Seriously; this is the first Star Trek season, ever. How could it not be classic, when such a season spawned not just two additional seasons, but also a "Next Generation" series, three spin-offs, and ten movies? These were great moments in classic sci-fi. Anyone who'd disagree, is, well...wrong.

You'll notice I fairly said "99%." What was the episode I didn't like too much, you ask? That would be the one where they try and find an old murderer, only to find he's a Shakespearean actor, or...whatever. I never really understood that one. Yet there's so much more classic moments to make this a must-own season. From the giant, single-celled alien brains that took over a colony in "Operation Annihilate," to the episode every Trek Fan Survey touts as the most favorite episode of all time, "City on the Edge of Forever," this season has it all, and a whole lot more.

I really don't want to bore you with the details. You're either a fan, or...well, if you're not, you don't know much about sci-fi, so why are you reading this? This is the definitive science fiction season to have on DVD, and now it's here. Let's just jump to the extras. Make it so.

The DVD :  First; the packaging! This season is in a "Captain's Gold" colored clamshell of sorts, that opens up vertically along the middle, with a hinge at the bottom. In the center of this clamshell is a small, jewel-case sort of collection of the many discs of the set. It is the front of this jewel case which can be seen through the window in front of the clamshell. Word is that the next two seasons of the series will be in similar packaging, only with Spock's blue colored uniform the color of season two, and Scotty's red uniform the color of season three. This is a pretty cool idea.

A packaging concept this ingenious can only be a sign of the ingenuity of the extras held within. Sadly, those extras would not include much in the way of audio commentary. Only "text" commentary is offered, as an option to only four random episodes. What's more; you'd be surprised which four they chose to comment on, since on of them isn't City on the Edge of Forever. So sadly; commentary is one feature sorely lacking.

That is the sole gripe I'll be stating here, however, with all other extras being top-notch. The season finale, Operation Annihilate, is on a disc all its own, with the rest of the video on that disc being nothing but extras. Let's begin with the core featurette, "The Birth of a Timeless Legacy." This 24 minute featurette is as intriguing as those similar featurettes on the DVD sets of Star Trek the Next Generation, if not more so, since they include anecdotes from the classic cast: Leonard Nimoy, William Shatner, and so on. This is the tale of how it all began. Cool.

Then there are separate featurettes. "Life Beyond Trek: William Shatner" is apparently one of similar featurettes which we'll see in later season sets. In this first installment, Shatner shows us his real life these days, post Star Trek, at his ranch. He also talks of his love for horses. This should be a real treat for all fans of both Kirk, and the actor playing him.

Not to be outdone, Nimoy has his time in the spotlight here, as well. "Reflections on Spock" gives Leonard Nimoy the chance to discuss his classic character, as well as his two dual books on the subject, titled ambiguously "I am Spock" and "I am not Spock."

Neither star would've been able to do much without great stories to work with, and that leads to the even better extra feature, of "Sci-Fi Visionaries." What makes this featurette all the nicer to see, is that the majority of these writers rarely get screen time in front of a camera. There are a lot of interviews with Trek's most renowned writers here, including new interviews with D.C. Fonatana, Bob Justman, and John D.F. Black. 

Then there is "To Boldly Go...(Season One)." This is another potential series of featurettes begun in this first season's DVD set. This feature in essence makes up for (slightly) the lack of commentary in the most popular episodes of the season, with anecdotes regarding such stories as "The Naked Time," "City on the Edge of Forever," "The Devil in the Dark," and "The Lonely Squire of Gothos."

Then there are the "red shirt logs." On the bonus disc, be sure to go to every menu screen possible (noting that the "more" pages count as other menu screens), and move the cursor around to try and find a button on the "consoles" that you can click on. Doing so reveals eight separate logs of various anecdotes, from the creative crew behind key episodes, to even Sulu's George Takei, who muses on his swordplay in Naked Time.

In the end, this was a long time in coming. The offering is just barely enough to have us all forget the near-decade of "two episodes per DVD," which was until now the only way to buy these episodes at all...and with not a single bonus feature! This is the way Star Trek deserves to be preserved for all time. Indeed; it's been a long time in coming...but seeing the final result, it was worth the wait. 

 

Final Rating : Deep Impact. Forget all the bleeding hearts for modern "sci-fi" crap-o-rama; this was sci-fi at its best 40 years ago, and it still is today.

For more on this site's ratings system, click here.

 

Click picture to order this 6-disc DVD set

Got a review you'd like to share? Techtite will post 2 of the best "guest" reviews received for any product, online, for all the world to see!

 

 

All text, Title graphics, and pix not of reviewed products, are created by Techtite, copyright 1999-2001; all rights reserved. Picture of DVD cover is used only for the purpose of review (and to make shopping for product easier); it by no means represents any affiliation with Techtite and the distributors of this product. For further "legalese" & disclaimers, click here...