Techtite's DVD Reviews!

--------------
MAIN PAGE
--------------
Reviews :
PC Games
Macintosh 
DVDs (& VHS!)
Movies (now playing)
Television
Gadgets & Gear
Hardcopy (Books)
Shows & Parks
X-box (360)
Playstation 3
Nintendo Wii
Game Cube
Nintendo DS
The PSP Page
Video Games (classic)
 

 Departments :

Snapshot of the Week:

  

Questions? Comments? Send Them To

Techtite Letters.

 

The Techtite Ratings System :

  • Burnout
  • Near Miss
  • Small Crater
  • Large Crater
  • Deep Impact

In Association with Amazon.com

Disney's Dinosaur

cover

Click this left picture to buy the One-Disc, regular DVD version

cover

Click this right Picture to buy the two-disc Collector's edition!

A Techtite Review

The Film : It's too bad the story of this film couldn't be worked on a bit more, especially for little kids. The plot involves the age of Dinosaurs on Earth, apparently soon before the infamous meteor landed, that engulfed the atmosphere in clouds and brought all dinosaurs to extinction. In a field teaming with dinosaur nests, a lone egg is left behind, after its parents attempt to flee a T-rex. We see this egg's journey, as it is clumsily carried away by a birdlike lizard, then dropped into the stream, then grabbed by a pterodactyl, and finally dropped onto an island far away. This island is inhabited by white monkeys, who decide to keep the baby dino as a pet; even if it is a predator. After all, when it grows up, it just might be good to have such a large friend on their side.

Things get complicated by the time Aladar grows up (voiced by D.B. Sweeney), when a meteor hits the Ocean, close to the shore. While this is not the infamous meteor that made dinosaurs extinct (no chance of a happy ending if it was, is there?), it is a meteor big enough to create a wave that destroys the small island. Swimming to the mainland coast is only half of their problems, because the wave also destroyed the other dinosaurs' homes near the mainland shore. Aladar, with his monkey friends on his back, joins the dino herd as it treks over a long desert to reach a new nesting grounds. This will be a perilous journey, because there are few stops for food or water along the way, and a pair of hungry T-rex are hot on their trail!

The film's storyline is admittedly dark, and with the vivid depiction of the T-rex predators, I'd definitely say the film is too intense for very young children. Aladar even has to get into a rather violent, unnecessary fight with Kron, the leader of the herd (surprisingly voiced by Samuel E. Wright, whose more lighthearted voice brought Sebastian the Crab to life in The Little Mermaid). True, Aladar has a nice budding romance (of sorts) with Kron's sister (voiced by Julianna Margulies), and the initial banter between them is quite funny (when she first sees him do something stupid to impress her, she says, "That, children, is a Jerkasaurus!"). However, with thirsty animals in the desert, vicious predators, and major nature challenges galore, there's just too little levity to keep young kids from at least one week of nightmares. Where's the comic animal duo of Timon and Pumbaa when you need them?

Sure, this is belittling the awesome effects of the film, which are revolutionary in CGI techniques of mainstream cinema. Swooping camera angles and visuals were taken of actual areas of nature --forests, waterfalls, oceans and deserts-- with the CGI dinosaur characters added to the scenes later. This is indeed an excellent approach to storytelling, and yet, sadly, the story told is a bit too basic to enjoy the film as much as you would hope. While CGI fans will love watching the film just for the visuals, it's a shame that such visuals weren't used for a loftier, more gripping Disney tale. The end result is a film that gets a thumbs up regardless of its flaws, yet still could've been much better.

The DVD : Pardon the length of this DVD section of the review; there's a lot to cover! Much like Disney's other digital animation films lately, there are two versions of DVD to choose from: a standard, one-DVD version, and a two-disc version, with tons of added extras. Are the added extras worth it? Let me review them for you...

The first disc is identical for both DVD versions. It includes the film (of course), created directly from the digital source, for a perfect digital picture (not transferred to film and back again, which would lead to a less quality picture on DVD). The screen in widescreen 1.85:1, and enhanced for 16x9 TVs. The sound is everything you'd want it to be, on one disc: DTS 5.1 digital surround sound is offered, plus Dolby digital. In addition, anyone studying French (or anyone from France, of course) will like the French language option.

Other features added to disc one (again, on both sets), makes one wonder how much they need the two-disc version. There's a lot on this one disc! Directors and Effects supervisors provide one audio commentary, while a second comment track is available, with anecdotes from the production team. A third audio option offers an Isolated sound effects audio track, as well as "TheatreVision" descriptive audio for the hearing impaired.

Another amusing addition is the "Film fact fossil dig," which is a trivia hunt of sorts which can be played either during the film or not. If played during the film, a fossil icon will appear on your screen, when a fun fact related to dinosaurs is related to that particular scene. click the enter key of your DVD remote to see the Film fact, then return to the film when you're done. Each of these are film clips, ranging from discussions of actual Lemurs (as shown in the film), to a pre-concept look of the opening sequence, and "live action shoots" that show how the real-life background jungle scenes were filmed, before the foreground CGI dinosaurs were added. In addition, three deleted scenes and an alternate ending are offered. Unfortunately, the deleted scenes were abondoned very early in production, with one only shown in storyboard sketches, and the other three shown mostly in pre-texture (one-color) models of the characters. Still, for computer graphics fans, it's amusing to see the step-by-step processes behind the making of the film.

Other added materials on disc-one should appeal to the kids in particular. "Aladar's Adventure" is a short adventure game kids can play, using the cursor controls on their DVD remote. It allows them to feel like they're helping Aladar through the mazes of caves to his new home. A "Dinopedia" offers scientific information of dinosaurs shown in the film, while a "Dinosearch" offers a sort of "Where's Waldo" style visual hunt, where certain dinosaur images are hidden in a big picture which you must search. Last of all, this disc is a DVD-ROM, offering the typical web links to sites relevant to the film. Macintosh owners, however, will appreciate these DVD-ROM features being compatible with Macs as well as PCs.

Which brings us to disc-2, of the Collector's Edition DVD set. Most of the items here are for the true fans of CGI, with a lot of behind the scenes technical info. The best addition for everyone, however, would have to be the added deleted scenes. AMong the 6 scenes offered, are scenes that were fully animated in CGI (though often, only made to the black-and-white stage), though were cut for time conscerns. One of the more amusing scenes (though sadly, only offered in storyboard animation) was an initial concept of Aladar being named "Noah" (?), and having Grandparents with him in the traveling herd. In a suggested poignant moment, his grandparents would sacrifice themselves to save the herd from the attacking carnataurs. I'd say this was a wise omission, even if it is amusing as a deleted scene.

Disc 2's best feature for behind-the-scenes buffs is a step-by-step look of the film's production tests, from as far back as March of 1996! You get to the the Proof of Concept Test from that date, the Live Action Backplate from the following October, the Early Presentation Reel from that December, and a Presentation Reel from later in production, in October of 1998. In addition, nine screens worth of 73 thumbnailed production images (which can be "zoomed in" at will) are offered. Elsewhere on the DVD, you can view a step-by-step look of the creation of the animated characters, as well as a step-by-step look at the production process itself. The music of the film is also saluted, with video clips showing how the music and sound effects were handled.

Disc 2 is capped off with all the promotional materials ever used for the film, including three different trailers, four different TV spots, and 14 different magazine advertisements (shown in thumbnails, that can be zoomed into if you wish). All this makes the choice between the two Dinosaur sets, both easy and hard at the same time. Easy, because it's really only a matter of how much you liked the film. However, should people who liked --not loved-- the film get the Collector's Edition 2-disc set? Perhaps, though only if you are intrigued by behind the scenes technical information, which is pretty much all that's offered. Otherwise, I'd say there's more than enough on the single disc version to keep you occupied for several added hours.

 

Final Rating : Small Crater. Definitely a bit too intense for young kids, and its story could be much better. Great FX, though; a major leap forward in cinema CGI.

For more on this site's ratings system, click here.

 

cover

Click this left picture to buy the One-Disc, regular DVD version

cover

Click this right Picture to buy the two-disc DVD Collector's edition!

 

 

Got a review you'd like to share? Techtite will post 2 of the best "guest" reviews received for each item, online, for all the world to see!

 

All text, Title graphics, and pix not of reviewed product, are created by Techtite, copyright 2000; all rights reserved. For further "legalese" & disclaimers, click here...